Reminiscent of sweet potato pie, these shortbread sweet potato squares are sweet and savory goodness
Simple, perfect and really unique, these zippy little cinnamon cookies are a holiday favorite
A delicious vegan cookie that sings with lemon flavor
Dark, earthy molasses cookie recipe with an ancient history
Who got the cranberries drunk again?
Pretty persimmons flavor these holiday spiced cookies
Holy basil, Batman. An odd cookie challenge turns out pretty tasty
Rich, chocolate cookies with a hint of heat and a tart tingle of dried fruit
Warm Hershey Kisses in the center are the secret of these snowballs
A shortbread cookie with spiced honey on top? Yes, please.
Filled with savory and sweet spices and sugar, it’s a unique take on the usual holiday cookie.
Move over Tollhouse, these cookies are doubly chocolately
The truest gingerbread cookie recipe I’ve found to date
Luxe chocolate cookies with a creamy peanut butter center are a hybrid of Whoopie pies and Oreos.
These buttery cookies are called Cat’s Tongue because of their shape
A spicy vegan cookie gets a lot of thumbs-up from tasters
Results of the cookie contest
Submitted by a professional caterer, I knew these would be amazing, but hands down, these are the best ginger snaps I’ve made to date. The fresh ginger adds a special zing you just can’t get in powdered ginger.
I love, love, love these potato chip cookies. They’ve got a shortbread base with the extra salty, crunchy flavor of the chips. Tasters loved these cookies as well. The bonus is that they’re amazingly easy to make.
There’s a lot going on in these little cookie cups — shortbread, nuts and chocolate chips. Tasters were mixed on their affinity toward them, but if you’re a shortbread fan, it’s worth trying these intriguing little treats.
Exotic flavors give these cookies an island feel
It’s a brownie. It’s a cookie. It’s a brownie cookie, the best of both worlds. What is especially great about these is how soft and chewy they are, as well as all the from-scratch taste.
Heavy cream and butter make these Danish Kringle cookies delish
Super soft and decadent. And that’s from someone who doesn’t usually do peanut butter. Extra love for the sugar tops.
Okay, suspend disbelief for a minute. This one sounds crazy, but like tomato soup cake, ends up remarkably well. The salty soda crackers give the toffee a solid base and add some savory to what could be mind-bendingly sweet.